合伙企业破产三题——以美国法为主要比较素材的分析Three Issues on the Partnership Bankruptcy——An Analysis Based on the American Laws as the Comparative Material
韩长印;何睿;
摘要(Abstract):
我国2006年8月修改颁布的《合伙企业法》已经赋予合伙企业以破产能力,但仅简单规定了其破产清算参照适用破产法规定的程序。由于合伙企业在组织形式、财产构成以及责任方式等方面与一般法人企业存在明显的差异,对企业破产法的参照适用中存在许多疑难问题亟待解决。
关键词(KeyWords): 合伙企业;破产申请;破产原因;破产财产
基金项目(Foundation): 上海市哲学社会科学规划项目“自然人破产法律问题研究”的阶段性成果(项目编号:2003BFX006)
作者(Author): 韩长印;何睿;
Email:
DOI:
参考文献(References):
- [1]Comm ittee on Rules of Practice and Procedure ofthe Jud icial Conference of the Bankruptcy Forms(Mar.1982).
- [2][19]潘琪.美国破产法[M].北京:法律出版社,1999.6,152.
- [3]BankruptcyAct§5b,52 Stat.at 845-46 and R.BANKR.P.105(b).(c).(d).
- [4]M ichaelA.Morris,Issues in Partnership Bankrupt-cy Cases.
- [5]§303.11 U.S.C§503(b)(3)(A).
- [6]Unif.Partnership ACT§40(b).
- [7]汤维建.优胜劣汰的法律机制——破产法要义.贵阳:贵州人民出版社,1995.60.
- [8]Perry S.Goldman,an Overview of BAnkruptcy Is-sues Affecting Partnerships.
- [9]House Report,at 197,reprinted in 1978 U.S.CodeCong.&ad.News at 6158.
- [10]沈达明,郑淑君.比较破产法初论[M].北京:对外贸易教育出版社,1993.33.
- [11]陈荣宗.破产法[M].台北:台湾三民书局,1986.41.
- [12]陈计男.破产法论[M].台北:台湾三民书局,1980.37-38.
- [13]李敏华,蓝承烈.制约合伙企业破产目标实现各要素的界定[J].社会科学家,2005,(6).
- [14]Mcgraw—H ill.Modern Businesslaw and Regulato-ry Enviroment.1996.695.
- [15]Dennis M.O’Dea.Kathryn L.Roseen,Issuesin Partnership Bankruptcy.
- [16]See Uniform Partnership Act 1992(with 1993,1994,1996,1997 Amendments)§202;转引自宋永新.美国非公司型企业法[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2000,53.
- [17]潘琪.美国破产法.法律出版社,1999.94.
- [18][25][美]大卫.G.爱泼斯坦,史蒂夫.H.尼克勒斯,詹姆斯.J.怀特.美国破产法[M].韩长印等译.北京:中国政法大学出版社,2003.367,303.
- [20][21]Steven A.W aters&Eric Terry,*51 Bank-ruptcy and Insolvency Issues for Partnerships,Lcs,and TheirOwners—The good,the bad,and the ug-ly,39-Spg Tex.J.Bus.L.51,Spring 2003.
- [22]Steven A.W aters&Eric Terry,51 Bankruptcyand Insolvency Issues for Partnerships,Llcs,andTheir Owners——The good,the bad,and the Ug-ly,39-Spg Tex.J.Bus.L.51,Spring 2003.
- [23]Nathan Levy JR,Bankruptcy handbook,littleBrown and Company,1993,P.470.
- [24]Perry S.Goldman,an Overview of Bankruptcy Is-sues Affecting Partnerships.
- ①参见《最高人民法院关于人民法院民事执行中查封、扣押、冻结财产的规定》第五条。
- ①因为美国有此类案例,在Partners v.Brennan一案中,法院认为合伙人在接受合伙企业财产分配时并不知道合伙企业的资产状况,并不知道其已经陷入了破产状态,因此可以推定其为善意的;同时由于合伙人转让给企业的财产价值大于其分配到的价值,因此该转让不应当撤销。Sally S.Neely,OUTLINE OF SELECTED PROBLEMS IN PARTNERSHIP AND PARTNER BANKRUPTCY.American Law Institute-AmericanBar Association Continuing Legal Education,ALI-ABA Course of Study,February 24,2000.